RE-IMAGINING GRANDMA'S FRENCH TOAST

CHEFS REMAKE OLD FAVORITES ALL THE TIME. ONE WRITER DECIDES TO USE THEIR TECHNIQUES AND ADVICE ON ONE OF HER FAVORITE MEALS.

These are the first two pieces of french toast in the pan. Photo by Jordan Schultz

These are the first two pieces of french toast in the pan. Photo by Jordan Schultz

By Jordan Schultz

My family’s famous French toast recipe has been around for 35 years. My grandma was the one who started making the dish, the instructions for which was on the packaging for an electric skillet that she got one Christmas. She made some adjustments though. The original recipe was rather simple, but hers was dressed up with nutmeg and vanilla. My aunt still makes the dish exactly that same way. My mother however found a few ways to improve the classic family dish. She doubles the vanilla.

I’ve always enjoyed spending time in kitchens. I’ve made the famous French toast alongside my mother and Grandmother many times. But I’d never really attempted it on my own. I hoped to create a unique version, a personal stamp the way my grandmother and mother did.

Professional chefs have a way of taking ordinary dishes – shrimp and grits, fried chicken, spaghetti – and making them their own. I decided that, in an attempt to make my own French toast, I’d take their approach. Like a professional chef, I’d give the classic recipe my own personal spin. I hoped it would elevate this important culinary experience I grew up with.

While anyone can follow a recipe and make food, it takes a true artist to re-imagine a dish and make it a unique creation. According to an interview found on YouTube done with Massimo Bottura, an internationally renowned Chef with his own restaurant in Modena, a chef’s inspiration can include anything from family recipes to cultural influences to art and or literature. Bottura also advises against messing too much with grandmothers’ recipes but acknowledges that dishes do tend to evolve and change over time.

...

I decided to go out and ask some local chefs how they approached adding a spin to long-time favorite menu items. The most popular dish at the Eight-Oh-Six Bistro in Fredericksburg, Virginia is the fish and chips, according to the owner Roberta Pacheco. Eight-Oh-Six Bistro, a Spanish-American restaurant downtown, says the recipe for that item is about 30 years old. She doesn’t try to mess with it; what makes it special is its authenticity. She also attributes the use of good quality fish.

A farm to fork restaurant, Bistro Bethem is also located in downtown Fredericksburg. The manager says that their most popular entrée is their free range chicken, appearing on the menu as FRC. The chickens are organic and are also cage free, as the name would suggest. But what makes it stand out is a secret mixture of herbs that it spends 24 hours in, which adds to its flavor. The side pairings are just as important, according to the manager. One of the more popular is their macaroni and cheese.

...

The process of creating my own version of French toast began when I compared my grandmother’s French toast recipe with my mother’s. I decided upon using my mother’s version because I love her secret with the vanilla. One catch is that I don’t have an electric skillet in my tiny apartment, which I share with two roommates. I had to make do with the stovetop and a frying pan. The recipe also calls for nutmeg, but as I looked though my cabinets all I could find was cinnamon. I decided that would be my first change, an improvisation born from necessity.

I still wanted to take my French toast a step further though, so I did some research on Pinterest to figure out how other people had dressed up the classic French toast. I found ideas ranging from French toast breakfast sandwiches to pumpkin spice French toast to a French toast topped with spiced apples. Seeing the hundreds of ways that people had already reinvented French toast was intimidating. How would I create something that was uniquely my own?

I sat around with my roommates as I tried to brainstorm what I might do. They weren’t much help though; all they wanted to do was eat whatever I made. I thought about adding fruit to my dish. My favorite fruit, pineapple. Then my mind started racing. Would I add it to the batter? That wouldn’t work. I guess it was going on top. I thought about the times I’d gone on vacation with my family to the beach and sipped on a virgin pina colada with a chunk of pineapple on the rim. That was it. I’d make pina colada French toast.

I decided to make Sunday brunch for my two roommates and a couple of friends. I went to Giant Food and Pharmacies in Fredericksburg to get my ingredients as well as a few extra items, in case I burned something. I woke up early the morning of my get-together and set to work making my mother’s version of French toast, with my small substitution - cinnamon. After each of my friends tried the “plain” version with syrup, I then served them another that was topped with whipped cream, pineapple chunks, and sprinkled with coconut.

When I bit into the first version, I was surprised by how little adding cinnamon changed the overall flavor. It didn’t seem to matter that much how much or what kind of spice was incorporated into the batter. Then, when I tried the version with the special toppings, my eyes lit up. I hadn’t been sure how the flavors would go together, but I was shocked and pleased how well the freshness of the pineapple mixed with the savory French toast.

Here is the final product of pina colada french toast. Photo taken by Jordan Schultz

Here is the final product of pina colada french toast. Photo taken by Jordan Schultz

My friends deemed the experiment a success. Two of them preferred the plain version while two preferred the Pina colada. Some of them thought the pineapple was an interesting addition that made the dish more unique. I enjoyed both.

The process of re-imagining such a revered family recipe such as French toast was a daunting thought, but I was happy that I took the chance. In regards to my kitchen experiences in the future, I will most likely stick with the recipe. However I definitely am no longer afraid to get a little creative when necessary. Who knows what you can create when you put on your own chef’s hat.