Try Not to Go Insane Challenge: Impossible

A Week Without Music: A week in the life of a girl obsessed with music forced to give up her headphones

By Alanah Cleare

It started as a challenge: one week without music. At first, it sounded simple—just press pause, right? But the silence that followed revealed more than I expected. Music had been my constant companion, filling every corner of my life with rhythm and melody. Without it, I had to confront moments I had always tuned out, distractions I never questioned, and thoughts I hadn’t allowed myself to hear. This is the story of what happened when I pressed mute on the soundtrack of my life.

Day 1: The First Night

2:00 am

The silence hit me harder than I thought it would. Normally, I’d drift off to the playlist of soft melodies, using music to block out the world, and, if I’m honest, my own thoughts. But tonight, I was left alone with the hum of the fridge, the occasional creak of the apartment walls, and the uneven rhythm of my breathing. Each sound was sharper, clearer, and oddly intrusive.

The creaking sounds bothered me in a way they never had before. Each groan of the building felt like a question I couldn’t quite grasp: Why did it sound so loud? Does this happen every night? Why couldn’t I ignore it? I realized that it wasn’t the sounds themselves but the silence surrounding them that amplified every little noise. My mind was in absolute chaos, racing without the familiar musical distraction to calm it. “Should I have said that in my conversation earlier? Did anyone catch the moment I stumbled over my words?

I stared at the ceiling, restless and uncomfortable. The silence wasn’t peaceful: it felt like a spotlight on all the little things I’d been wanting to avoid.

Day 2: Cooking Without Headphones

5:00 pm

Dinner prep felt awkward. I stood at the stove, stirring pasta sauce in complete silence. Normally, I’d wear my headphones, losing myself in a playlist that turned chopping vegetables into something almost cinematic. But without them, the kitchen became a stage, and every sound took center.

The sauce bubbled softly, the pots rattled when I moved them, and the knife’s steady thuds on the cutting board echoed in the quiet. The spoon scraping the saucepan sounded almost grating, and I could hear the faint murmur of a TV show playing in the living room.

Without music, my thoughts had nowhere to hide. “Did anyone hear my stomach rumble in class today? This is a very strong onion…why is this onion so strong…AM I GOING TO DIE?!?!” Normally, I’d rely on music to drown out these ridiculous thoughts, but in the stillness, they came through loud and clear, demanding my attention like static on an empty radio station

As the minutes passed, something shifted. The kitchen sounds weren’t just noise—they were rhythmic and grounding. For the first time, I noticed how the bubbling sauce seemed to sync with my movements, how the clinks and clatters formed an accidental melody of their own. I didn’t need music to fill the space; the sounds around me were enough.

Day 3: At the Gym

9:45 am

Working out without music was weird. Usually, I’d blast an energizing playlist to push me through every set, matching the beat to my movements. Today, all I had were the clinks of weights, the faint pop songs playing over the gym’s speakers, and the sound of my own breathing.

It felt harder to stay motivated without the driving force of a beat. I noticed things I never had before: the uneven rhythm of my breath, the creak of the gym floor beneath my shoes, and the muffled conversations around me. Each rep felt heavier, each moment longer.

I couldn’t help but wonder if the music had been more of a crutch than I’d realized. Without it, I had to tune into my body—the tightening and relaxing of muscles, the way my heart raced. It was uncomfortable, almost too raw.

I thought about how often I drown out the sounds of life, not just at the gym but everywhere. Was I pushing through the day without really feeling it? Without the music, would I move more slowly, breathe more deeply, or let myself simply be?

Day 4: Walking to Class

11:30 am

Walking to class today without my headphones, I felt exposed. Usually, I’d use them as armor, a signal to the world that I wasn’t available for interaction. But today, there was nothing between me and the people around me.

I heard the crunch of leaves beneath my shoes, snippets of conversations from students passing by, and the never-ending sounds of the construction on campus in the distance. Without my headphones, I couldn’t avoid the friendly nods or waves from classmates. I even stopped to chat with someone I hadn’t spoken to in weeks.

It wasn’t all bad, but it was strange. I’d spent so much time using music to shield myself that I didn’t realize how often I’d avoided connection. The silence made me feel vulnerable but also opened up space for things I hadn’t expected—like the possibility of being seen and the challenge of seeing others.

This experiment didn’t just change my relationship with music; it changed my relationship with myself. I learned that silence isn’t just the absence of sound—it’s the presence of everything we’ve been avoiding. In the quiet moments, we hear the world and, maybe, ourselves.